First squishy mail in Maine

Two and Four Color Brioche, A Designer’s Tale

Lindsay LewchukAnnouncements, Multicolored (2026 theme), Pattern Related Leave a Comment

Before moving from NC I had a dream to design an intro to brioche set of shawls – one featuring two colors and the other, four colors.  In my knitting brain I’d decided on all the details from the short rows to the shape and started working on the two-color version.  I finished it shortly after moving to Maine and the four color version became part of my first yarn purchase delivery from Five Wise Owls in my new home.

Shortly thereafter reality set in.  As I started to knit the four color version following the original pattern, I realized something wasn’t going quiet right.  My stitch count grew faster than it did on the original.  My rows completed the repeats before all the required rows were worked.  Frogged and tried again and again and again.  The same issues were popping up!  What was going on?

The project went into the sin bin while the little grey cells began to compute the results of the experiment:

(notation note: “original” is the 2 color version, Brioche Step Shawl; “new” is the 4 color version, Brioche Step Up Shawl)

  1. Number of passes – original had 2 passes per row (rs & ws); new had 4 passes per row (rs & ws in A, rs & ws in B).
  2. Number of increases – original kfyobyof increased 4 sts; new kfyobyof increased 8 sts!
  3. Shape – original was turning out super long with 5 blocks of colorwork; new was turning out super deep and running out of yarn consistently

Time chugged by and I thought I must have made a mistake so again with the same bad results.  Tried tweaking a thing here and a thing there, but it really wasn’t working. 

Do you see what was happening?  It finally clicked – I wasn’t comparing apples to oranges – the additional color created extra passes! The additional color (because my increases held double stranded) doubled the increases!  Both of these factors changed the shape!

So after much time in the sin bin while I chewed on the problem, I decided to make them complementary sister patterns instead of identical.  Throwing out the idea of knitting 2 patterns from one set of directions, I chatted with the 4 color design and determined how many blocks of short rows it wanted and how wide and deep it wanted to be.  Then following the general concept of the original, I rewrote the new to fit with how 4 color brioche works differently than 2 color brioche.

The educational value of up-skilling still holds!  Though not identical patterns, you get a flavor of familiarity and two lovely shawls that hopefully challenge your brioche skill building.  Happy knitting!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *